MySetPlan vs Fitbod: Which Is Better?
Two popular workout apps. Two very different approaches. One builds a structured plan. The other generates random workouts. Here is how they compare.
MySetPlan wins for most people. It costs less ($6.99-$13.99/mo vs $15.99/mo), includes nutrition, and gives you a real plan that gets harder over time. Fitbod is better if you hate routine and want a different workout every day.
Both MySetPlan and Fitbod help you work out. But they do it in completely different ways. The right choice depends on what you actually want from a workout app.
Fitbod is popular because it generates fresh workouts every session. Open the app, and you get a new routine based on what muscles need work. It sounds great in theory.
MySetPlan takes the opposite approach. It builds a structured program that you follow for a full month. Same exercises. Progressive weights. Built-in recovery weeks. It is the kind of plan a personal trainer would write.
Quick Comparison
| Feature | MySetPlan | Fitbod |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly price | $6.99-$13.99 | $15.99 |
| Structured program | ||
| Progressive overload | ||
| Recovery weeks | ||
| Nutrition targets | ||
| Different workout daily | ||
| Muscle balancing | ||
| Free trial | 7 days | 3 workouts |
How Fitbod Works
Random workouts every session
Fitbod uses AI to generate a new workout each time. It looks at your workout history, figures out which muscles are recovered, and picks exercises for those muscles. You never do the same workout twice.
This sounds fun. And for some people, it is. But there is a problem.
If your exercises change every session, you cannot track progressive overload. You might bench press on Monday, then not bench press again for two weeks. By then, you have lost the adaptation. You are starting over.
Fitbod is great for variety seekers. It is not great for people who want to systematically get stronger.
How MySetPlan Works
Structured monthly programs
MySetPlan builds you a complete program for the month. Same exercises each week. Progressive sets and reps. Every 4th week is a recovery week. This is how real strength programs work.
With MySetPlan, you can track your progress on every lift. Did you bench press 135 lbs for 8 reps last week? This week, go for 9. Or add 5 lbs. That is progressive overload. That is how you get stronger.
The recovery weeks are important too. Your body adapts during rest, not during training. Fitbod does not schedule rest. You have to remember to take it.
Progressive Overload: The Key Difference
- Same exercises for 3-4 weeks
- Reps and sets increase weekly
- Can track strength gains
- Built-in deload weeks
- Different exercises daily
- No planned progression
- Hard to track gains
- No scheduled recovery
Nutrition Features
MySetPlan includes nutrition
MySetPlan gives you calorie and macro targets based on your goal. Building muscle? You get a slight surplus. Losing fat? A moderate deficit. Protein targets are calculated for your body weight. Fitbod does not offer any nutrition features.
Training is half the equation. Nutrition is the other half. If you are paying for a workout app, having nutrition included adds real value.
Pricing Comparison
MySetPlan costs less
MySetPlan: $6.99 to $13.99 per month. Fitbod: $15.99 per month. Over a year, MySetPlan saves you $24 to $108 — and includes nutrition and structured programming that Fitbod does not offer.
Who Should Pick Which?
Choose MySetPlan if you:
- Want to get stronger with measurable progress
- Prefer following a structured plan
- Want nutrition guidance included
- Care about recovery and avoiding burnout
- Want to save money ($6.99 vs $15.99)
Choose Fitbod if you:
- Get bored doing the same exercises
- Want variety over structure
- Are just maintaining fitness, not building it
- Do not care about tracking progressive overload
The Bottom Line
Fitbod is a fine app for casual gym-goers who want variety. But if you are serious about getting results, you need structure. You need progressive overload. You need recovery weeks. You need nutrition.
MySetPlan gives you all of that for less money than Fitbod charges for random workouts. That is why it is our top pick.
Related Articles
Frequently Asked Questions
Is MySetPlan better than Fitbod?
For structured training and long-term progress, yes. MySetPlan builds a consistent plan that gets harder over time. Fitbod gives you different workouts every session. If you want structure and measurable progress, MySetPlan is better. If you want variety and do not care about following a program, Fitbod works.
What is the main difference between MySetPlan and Fitbod?
MySetPlan is a planning service. It builds a structured program for you to follow for a full month. Fitbod is a workout generator. It creates a new workout every time you open the app. MySetPlan prioritizes progressive overload and consistency. Fitbod prioritizes variety and muscle balancing.
Which is cheaper, MySetPlan or Fitbod?
MySetPlan is cheaper. It costs $6.99 to $13.99 per month depending on your plan. Fitbod costs $15.99 per month. Over a year, MySetPlan saves you $24 to $108 compared to Fitbod.
Does Fitbod have progressive overload?
Fitbod adjusts weights based on your logged performance, but because the exercises change every session, true progressive overload is difficult. You cannot track your bench press progress if you do not bench press consistently. MySetPlan keeps exercises the same for weeks so you can progressively add weight.
Can I build muscle with Fitbod?
You can maintain muscle and general fitness with Fitbod. But optimal muscle building requires progressive overload on the same exercises over time. Fitbod is better for variety seekers and general fitness. MySetPlan is better for people who want to build strength and muscle systematically.
Does MySetPlan or Fitbod include nutrition?
MySetPlan includes nutrition targets with calorie and macro recommendations based on your goals. Fitbod does not include nutrition features. If nutrition guidance matters to you, MySetPlan offers more value.
Content grounded in exercise science research and practical lifting experience. Learn more about our approach on the About page.